Sorque home

Equipment guide

Types of heat exchangers, common problems and maintenance

Heat exchangers transfer heat between two fluids through a solid wall, and almost every process plant relies on them as coolers, heaters, condensers, reboilers and interchangers. This guide covers the main types of heat exchangers used in industry, the problems engineers and technicians see most often, what to check during maintenance, and how to choose between designs.

Most trouble comes from deposits on the heat transfer surface, leaks through tubes, plates or gaskets, and damage from corrosion, vibration or thermal cycling. The right type depends less on headline efficiency than on how dirty, hot and high-pressure the service is and how the unit will be cleaned.

Peer reviews from Sorque users appear below the guide. The section on what people are saying elsewhere is a web summary of forums and trade articles, not a peer review.

Updated · Written for engineers, mechanics, and technicians

Web summary · not a peer review

What people are saying elsewhere

Fouling dominates trade writing on exchanger performance, and authors favor cleaning on trended performance rather than by the calendar. On forums, tube leaks are the other big topic, and experienced members want to know where and why a tube failed before it is plugged. Plate units are praised for compact, close-approach duty but draw complaints about gaskets and hard-to-find internal leaks, while air cooler threads center on dirty fins and plugs that fail in cycling service.

  • Fouling is the main performance killer. Trade authors rank fouling as the leading cause of lost exchanger efficiency. They advise recording clean performance, trending heat transfer and pressure drop, and sampling deposits at shutdowns before choosing a cleaning method.[1, 3, 4]
  • Find the root cause before plugging a leak. In threads on a leaking reboiler and an air cooler, respondents first asked whether the leak was at the tube joint or in the tube, and whether a root cause analysis had been done. In the reboiler thread, thermal shock, corrosion, vibration, overpressure and wrong materials were all listed as candidates.[11, 14]
  • Plate units need gasket attention. Gasket replacement can become a recurring cost on plate units. For an internal plate-pack leak, a forum member advised checking plates one at a time, suspecting corrosion under the gaskets, and keeping a spare plate set.[2, 12]
  • Air coolers lose capacity to dirty fins. A users group guideline for air-cooled condensers explains that dense fin banks trap airborne debris, and leaking fan gearbox oil binds dirt to the fins and resists washing.[15]

Summarized in our own words from the forum discussions and articles listed under Sources. These are other people’s reports, not Sorque peer reviews, and they never count toward ratings.

Types of heat exchangers and how they differ

Industrial heat exchangers are usually grouped by construction. Shell-and-tube and plate designs cover most liquid duties; the others solve specific problems such as no cooling water, heavy solids or very viscous products. Counterflow allows the closest approach and handles temperature crosses; parallel flow cannot produce a cross, and a multipass shell-and-tube shell tolerates only a small one.

Shell-and-tube heat exchangers

One fluid flows through a tube bundle and the other around the tubes inside a shell, guided by baffles. Fixed tubesheet, U-tube and floating head designs differ in how they absorb thermal expansion and whether the bundle can be pulled. Mechanical design is commonly specified to TEMA standards.

Best for
High pressures and temperatures, steam heating, condensing and reboiling, and fouling fluids routed through straight, mechanically cleanable tubes. Chemical Processing says the fixed tubesheet type typically has the lowest capital cost per unit of area.
Watch out for
On fixed tubesheet units the shell side can only be cleaned chemically, and Chemical Processing recommends a stress check when average fluid temperatures differ by more than about 35°C. U-bends make mechanical tube-side cleaning difficult.

Gasketed plate-and-frame heat exchangers

A pack of thin corrugated plates is bolted between frame plates. Gaskets direct the two fluids into alternating channels, usually in counterflow, and the corrugations create high turbulence even at modest velocities.

Best for
Liquid-to-liquid duties at low to moderate pressure that need a close approach, a small footprint, or capacity that can be raised by adding plates. Chemical Processing puts their heat transfer rates at typically three to five times those of conventional shell-and-tube units.
Watch out for
Gaskets limit temperature, pressure and chemical compatibility, and some services wear through them quickly. Narrow channels plug with fibers and particles.

Brazed plate heat exchangers

Stainless steel plates are brazed into a sealed block with no gaskets or frame.

Best for
Small, clean duties such as refrigerant evaporators and condensers, hydronic loops and oil coolers.
Watch out for
The pack cannot be opened, so cleaning is chemical only and an internal leak usually means replacement. Braze metal must suit the fluids; copper braze, for example, is unsuitable for ammonia.

Welded and semi-welded plate heat exchangers

Fully welded designs join every plate, sometimes as a block or inside a pressure shell. Semi-welded designs weld plates in pairs, so one fluid sees only welds while the other side stays gasketed.

Best for
Aggressive, toxic or refrigerant service beyond gasket limits, where plate-type performance is still wanted.
Watch out for
Welded channels usually can only be cleaned chemically, though some block designs have removable panels. Repairs often mean replacing plate pairs or the whole pack.

Double-pipe and hairpin heat exchangers

One fluid flows through an inner pipe or small tube bundle and the other through the surrounding pipe or shell, with the two legs joined by a return bend, normally in pure counterflow.

Best for
Small duties, high pressures and close approaches. Chemical Processing notes that hairpin units suit streams carrying solids, high tube-side pressures and very unequal flow rates.
Watch out for
Large duties need many sections, which takes space and adds flanged joints to maintain.

Air-cooled heat exchangers

Process fluid flows through finned tube bundles while fans force or draw ambient air across them, so no cooling water is needed.

Best for
Sites short on water, remote facilities, and refinery, gas plant and power plant coolers and condensers.
Watch out for
Capacity falls as ambient temperature rises. Fins foul and bend easily, and fans and drives add rotating equipment to maintain.

Spiral heat exchangers

Two metal sheets are wound around a core into two spiral channels, one per fluid, usually in counterflow. Gasketed end covers open for cleaning.

Best for
Sludges, slurries, and viscous or fouling fluids. Because each fluid has a single channel, a deposit raises the local velocity, which tends to scour it away.
Watch out for
Internal repairs are difficult, and parts and repair expertise are less common than for shell-and-tube units.

Scraped-surface heat exchangers

Rotating blades continuously scrape the inside wall of a jacketed tube so product cannot build up.

Best for
Very viscous, sticky or crystallizing products. Chemical Engineering magazine lists them for products that would otherwise foul badly or transfer heat poorly.
Watch out for
Blades, seals and drives need regular maintenance, and cost per unit of area is high.

Common heat exchanger problems and how to fix them

Most problems first show up as drifting outlet temperatures, a rising pressure drop, or contamination of the cleaner stream. Diagnosis is far easier when these are trended against a clean baseline.

Fouling, scaling and rising pressure drop

Symptoms
Outlet temperatures drift, duty and the overall heat transfer coefficient (U) fall, pressure drop climbs, and more steam, cooling water or pumping power is needed.
Likely causes
Scale, sediment, corrosion products, biological growth and baked-on product insulate the surface and narrow the passages. Chemical Processing names unexpected thermal reactions, below-design velocities, incompatible mixtures and organic and inorganic deposits as the main causes, and Chemical Engineering magazine cautions that pressure drop alone is an unreliable indicator.
What to do
Clean when trended U or approach crosses a trigger, and analyze a deposit sample to choose the cleaning method. Keep velocities at design, control cooling water chemistry and stop debris upstream. For chronic fouling, put the dirty fluid in straight tubes, consider corrugated tubes, keep a spare bundle, or change type.
Sources
1, 3, 4

Tube leaks and cross-contamination

Symptoms
One fluid turns up in the other, such as hydrocarbon in condensate or cooling water, or conductivity, pH or analyzer alarms trip.
Likely causes
Corrosion, erosion at tube inlets, vibration wear at baffles, thermal shock during startups and trips, overpressure, unsuitable materials, or a failed tube-to-tubesheet joint.
What to do
Have qualified personnel locate the leak with a pressure test within the allowable test pressure, then check the other tubes with eddy current, remote field or internal rotary ultrasonic testing. Find out whether the joint or tube failed, and why, before plugging. When plugging erodes capacity, plan a retube or new bundle; one experienced forum member warned that cutting out welded tubes in the field can ruin the tubesheet.
Sources
5, 11, 13, 16

Plate heat exchanger gasket and internal leaks

Symptoms
Drips or spray from the plate pack, or contamination of one fluid by the other with no visible external leak.
Likely causes
Aged or heat-hardened gaskets, gasket material incompatible with the fluid or cleaning chemicals, a pack tightened to the wrong dimension, and corrosion under a gasket or pinholes through a plate.
What to do
Replace gaskets with a compatible material and tighten the pack to the specified dimension. For internal leaks, open the pack and check plates individually, for example with dye penetrant; a spare plate set shortens the outage.
Sources
2, 12

Corrosion and erosion

Symptoms
Wall thinning or pitting found by testing, eroded tube ends at the inlet, and corrosion products showing up in deposits.
Likely causes
Materials unsuited to the real chemistry or temperature, corrosion hidden under deposits, galvanic couples, condensate corrosion in steam service, and impingement at inlet nozzles.
What to do
Review materials against actual operating conditions, including excursions above design temperature; API RP 571 is the usual damage mechanism reference. Keep surfaces clean, maintain impingement protection and trend wall thickness.
Sources
3, 11

Flow-induced tube vibration

Symptoms
Loud noise from the shell, leaking tubes and tube joints, tubes worn through at baffle holes, and higher shell-side pressure drop than predicted.
Likely causes
Shell-side flow beyond what the unsupported tube spans can tolerate, often after a rate increase, a fluid change or a retube with different tubes. Mechanisms include vortex shedding, turbulent buffeting and fluidelastic instability.
What to do
Have a specialist rerun the vibration check for any change in rate or service. Remedies include lower shell-side velocity, added tube supports, a different baffle arrangement or better inlet distribution.
Sources
6

Thermal stress and tube joint failures

Symptoms
Leaking tube-to-tubesheet joints, bowed or cracked tubes, or leaks that appear after startups, shutdowns or trips.
Likely causes
Large shell-to-tube temperature differences on fixed tubesheet units, rapid heating or quenching, and repeated cycling. In one forum case, standard plugs would not stay tight in an air cooler cycling between about 300°C and 50°C.
What to do
Change temperatures gradually and avoid sending cold fluid into a hot unit. Where differential expansion is large, use a U-tube, floating head or expansion joint, and treat repeat joint leaks as a design problem.
Sources
2, 11, 14

Air-cooled exchanger capacity loss

Symptoms
Outlet temperature climbs on warm afternoons, fans run flat out, and debris or oily dirt coats the fin face.
Likely causes
Fins trap insects, seeds, leaves and trash, leaking gearbox oil binds dirt to them, and bent fins, air bypass gaps and wrong fan pitch cut airflow.
What to do
A users group guideline for air-cooled condensers advises washing at controlled pressure with the spray parallel to the fins and that cell’s fan off, so debris is not drawn back in and tubes are not distorted by quenching. Lock out the fan first, then straighten fins, seal bypass gaps, fix gearbox leaks and check fan pitch.
Sources
15

Hidden cracking in hot hydrogen service

Symptoms
Usually none before a leak or rupture.
Likely causes
The U.S. Chemical Safety Board found that high temperature hydrogen attack cracked the carbon steel of a refinery exchanger that ruptured in 2010, killing seven workers. The failed section had likely run where industry prediction curves indicated it was safe.
What to do
Leave this to qualified materials and inspection engineers applying API practices such as API RP 941 within the plant’s process safety program. The CSB judged inspection for this damage unreliable and favored more resistant high-chromium steels.
Sources
7, 8

Rating heat exchangers on Sorque

Every Sorque review scores equipment from 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A, on the same five metrics. For heat exchangers, these are the things worth weighing:

Effectiveness
Does it deliver design duty and outlet temperatures across real flows and seasons, and how close an approach does it hold? Note how long it stays on spec after cleaning.
Reliability
Consider time between tube or gasket leaks, vibration damage and joint failures, and whether they came from the equipment or from operation outside its design.
Maintenance
How easy is it to open, clean and inspect? Compare pullable bundles and removable plate packs with welded or brazed units that allow chemical cleaning only, and include gasket and plate costs.
Efficiency
How well does it hold its heat transfer coefficient between cleanings, and how much pressure drop, and therefore pump or fan energy, does the duty cost?
Downtime/replaceability
Consider how quickly it can be isolated, opened, repaired and returned to service, whether it can be bypassed, spare bundle, plate and gasket availability, and remaining plugging margin.

Heat exchanger maintenance checklist

Most heat exchangers have no moving parts, so maintenance is about watching performance, keeping surfaces clean and finding damage before it leaks. Base intervals on trend data, manufacturer recommendations and the plant inspection program. Under OSHA’s process safety management standard, exchangers in covered processes are generally treated as pressure vessels for mechanical integrity: written procedures, inspection and testing to recognized good engineering practice, and documented results.

  • Record a clean baseline after commissioning and each cleaning (temperatures, flows, pressure drops and calculated U), and set cleaning triggers on loss of U, approach or pressure drop rather than a fixed calendar.
  • Keep upstream strainers, filters and backflush systems working.
  • On cooling water service, confirm water treatment is in control and watch the cooling water outlet temperature; hotter water scales faster.
  • Walk down for leaks at gaskets and flanges, corrosion at supports and nozzles, and unusual noise or vibration.
  • When the unit is open, sample and photograph deposits before flushing, and inspect tube ends, tubesheets, baffles and gasket faces.
  • Trend tube wall loss with eddy current, remote field or internal rotary ultrasonic testing to plan retubes before leaks start.
  • Leak test before return to service, and keep a map of plugged tubes against the allowable plugging margin.
  • On plate units, track gasket age, confirm gasket material suits the fluids and cleaning chemicals, and tighten the pack to the specified dimension.
  • On air-cooled units, clean fins with the fan off and locked out, check fan pitch and drives, and fix gearbox oil leaks.
  • Before opening any exchanger, follow site lockout, isolation, draining, decontamination and confined-space procedures. Leave hydroblasting to trained crews, and pressure tests and pressure-boundary repairs to qualified personnel working to the applicable code.

How to choose the right heat exchanger

Start from the process conditions and the maintenance your site can support, not from a catalog efficiency figure.

Pressure and temperature
Gaskets limit plate units, so high pressures and temperatures usually point to shell-and-tube, double-pipe or welded designs, with a U-tube, floating head or expansion joint where shell and tube temperatures differ widely. In the U.S., pressure-retaining exchangers are generally built to ASME Section VIII Division 1, which covers vessels operating above 15 psig.
Fouling and cleanability
Dirty or scaling fluids need passages that can be opened: straight tubes for mechanical cleaning, or a spiral or scraped-surface unit. Reserve brazed and fully welded units for clean fluids.
Temperature approach
Close approaches and temperature crosses favor counterflow plate, spiral or double-pipe units; a multipass shell-and-tube design may need several shells in series.
Fluid phase and properties
Large volumes of low-pressure vapor need big flow areas, favoring shell-and-tube or air-cooled designs; plate units condense and evaporate mainly at higher pressures or small vapor flows, as in refrigeration. Viscous or crystallizing products may need scraped-surface or spiral units.
Materials
Check tubes, plates, gaskets and braze metal against actual chemistry, chlorides, temperatures and cleaning chemicals. Material choice is the main defense against damage inspection can miss.
Space and utilities
Plate units save floor space. Air coolers save water but need plot space and fan power, and lose capacity in hot weather.
Maintenance access and spares
Leave room to pull bundles or open plate packs, and stock spares for critical services. Standard TEMA designations make like-for-like replacement bundles easier to specify.
Total cost of ownership
Weigh purchase price against cleaning, gaskets, pump or fan energy and lost production. Peer reviews of the same type in similar service help check vendor claims.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main types of heat exchangers?

The main industrial types are shell-and-tube, plate (gasketed, brazed and welded), double-pipe or hairpin, air-cooled, spiral and scraped-surface exchangers. They are also classified by flow arrangement: counterflow, parallel flow and crossflow.

What is the most common type of heat exchanger in the process industry?

Shell-and-tube, which trade sources such as Chemical Processing describe as the most common exchanger in plants. It tolerates high pressures and temperatures, copes with fouling fluids, and works for heating, cooling, condensing and boiling.

Which is more efficient, a plate or a shell-and-tube heat exchanger?

For clean liquids at moderate pressure, a plate exchanger usually transfers more heat per unit of area and holds a closer approach; Chemical Processing puts its heat transfer rates at typically three to five times those of conventional shell-and-tube units. Shell-and-tube wins where pressure, temperature, phase change or heavy fouling would defeat gaskets or narrow channels.

What causes heat exchanger fouling?

Fouling is unwanted material building up on the heat transfer surface: scale, sediment, corrosion products, biological growth and baked-on product. Low velocities, hot walls, unexpected reactions and incompatible mixtures make it worse, and the deposit insulates the surface so duty falls.

What is a fouling factor in a heat exchanger?

A fouling factor, or fouling resistance, is the extra thermal resistance a designer allows for deposits when sizing an exchanger; in operation it can be estimated as 1/U fouled minus 1/U clean. Chemical Engineering magazine warns that padding it to stretch cleaning intervals can end up requiring more frequent cleaning. One reason is that the extra area tends to lower velocities, which encourages deposits.

How often should heat exchangers be cleaned?

There is no universal interval. Record performance when the unit is clean, then clean when U, approach temperature or pressure drop crosses a trigger that balances cleaning cost against lost energy and throughput. For power plant air-cooled condensers, a users group guideline says finned tubes typically need cleaning about once a year, though site conditions change that.

What causes a heat exchanger tube to leak?

Common causes are corrosion, inlet erosion, vibration wear at baffles, thermal shock during startups and trips, overpressure and unsuitable materials. Leaks can also start at the tube-to-tubesheet joint, so find out where and why before plugging.

How do you find a leak in a shell-and-tube heat exchanger?

A common method is to remove the channel heads, pressurize the shell side, and watch the tube ends and joints; floating head units need a test ring. Eddy current, remote field or internal rotary ultrasonic testing then finds thinned tubes that have not leaked yet. Pressure tests should be done by qualified personnel within the allowable test pressure.

How many tubes can be plugged in a heat exchanger?

There is no code-mandated number; it depends on design margin, service and owner standards. One exchanger fabricator’s rule of thumb is that most processes tolerate plugging about 5 to 10 percent of the tubes before heat transfer falls well short of design. Each plug raises velocity and pressure drop in the remaining tubes, so rerun the thermal rating as plugs accumulate.

Peer reviews of heat exchangers

Rated 1 to 10 by engineers, mechanics, and technicians who have run or maintained them.

Add an equipment review

Ratings1 (poor) - 10 (great), N/A (Not applicable)

How well does it achieve its intended purpose, e.g., measurement accuracy of sensors. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

How likely is it to fail or seize. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

Effort and attention needed to maintain high quality operation. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

Performance/cost - can be energy, economic, or other costs. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

Length of time from breakdown to operation and ease of securing replacements. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

At least 20 characters. Reviews are public; leave out names and confidential details.

Sources

Pages this guide draws on, checked when it was last updated. Links go to other sites.

  1. Energy Saver: Avoid fouled exchangers · Chemical Processing
  2. Optimizing Heat Exchangers in Chemical Processing: Shell-and-Tube vs. Plate Types · Chemical Processing
  3. Managing fouling in heat exchangers · Chemical Engineering
  4. Heat exchanger fouling assessment · Heat Exchanger World
  5. Critical importance of heat exchanger inspection · Heat Exchanger World
  6. STV-1 Tube Vibrations in Shell-and-Tube Heat Exchangers (report abstract) · Heat Transfer Research, Inc. (HTRI)
  7. CSB Investigation Finds 2010 Tesoro Refinery Fatal Explosion Resulted from High Temperature Hydrogen Attack Damage to Heat Exchanger · U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board
  8. 29 CFR 1910.119 Process safety management of highly hazardous chemicals · Occupational Safety and Health Administration
  9. BPVC Section VIII Rules for Construction of Pressure Vessels Division 1 · ASME
  10. TEMA Standards · Tubular Exchanger Manufacturers Association
  11. Reboiler Tube Leak · Cheresources.com Community (Industrial Professionals forum)
  12. Leak In Plate Heat Exchanger · Cheresources.com Community (Industrial Professionals forum)
  13. Stainless Steel Hex: Retubing On Site · Cheresources.com Community (Process Heat Transfer forum)
  14. Fin Fan Cooler · Cheresources.com Community (Process Heat Transfer forum)
  15. ACC.02: Guidelines for Finned Tube Cleaning in Air-Cooled Condensers · Air Cooled Condenser Users Group
  16. Top Seven Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger Failure Mechanisms (#1 - Tube Plugging) · Ward Vessel and Exchanger