Sorque home

Equipment guide

Industrial pumps: types, problems, maintenance and selection

Industrial pumps move water, chemicals, fuels, slurries and viscous products through almost every process plant and use a large share of its power: a U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) sourcebook puts pumps at 27% of the electricity used by industrial systems in manufacturing. This guide covers the main types of industrial pumps, common failures, maintenance and selection.

Many repeat failures start outside the pump: a duty far from the best efficiency point (BEP), a starved suction, piping forced onto the nozzles, or the wrong seal arrangement. Fixing the system usually does more for run time than stronger parts.

Below the guide, Sorque users post peer reviews of specific pumps covering effectiveness, reliability, maintenance, efficiency and downtime.

Updated · Written for engineers, mechanics, and technicians

Web summary · not a peer review

What people are saying elsewhere

Forum threads and trade articles keep returning to one idea: a pump that fails repeatedly is usually pointing at a problem in the system. The causes named most often are running below minimum flow, thin NPSH margin, oversizing, and pipe strain or misalignment. For excess head, forum replies favor an impeller trim as the cheapest permanent fix and a variable speed drive where flow varies widely. Minimum flow has no universal number; it depends on the individual pump.

  • Measure before replacing parts. Trade troubleshooting guidance compares measured head and flow with the pump curve before anyone opens the casing, and a Plant Services root-cause column applies the same discipline to repeat failures. On the Cheresources forum, an engineer asking how to stop recurring seal and bearing failures was told to find the cause of each one first.[5, 9, 10]
  • Low flow is a common root cause. A Cheresources reply names two things behind many seal and bearing failures: running below the manufacturer’s minimum flow, which deflects the shaft, and cavitation from thin NPSH. Another thread stresses that minimum flow is pump-specific and should come from the vendor. A Chemical Processing columnist cites vane failures within weeks at 75% of BEP flow, while other pumps ran near shutoff for years.[8, 10, 11]
  • Excess head: throttle, trim or slow down. In a Cheresources thread on a pump with far more head than needed, replies note that a control valve can absorb the surplus but controls poorly when nearly closed, and that trimming the impeller is usually the cheaper option, easily justified when energy is expensive. Another thread suggests a variable speed drive where flow varies widely.[11, 12]
  • Seals fail because of what surrounds them. A Fluid Sealing Association column in Pumps & Systems cites plant surveys that attribute 70% of pump failures to misalignment, and site failure studies that found pipe strain in more than 80% of chronic failures. Hydraulic Institute guidance suggests keeping seal chamber pressure at least 25 psi (175 kPa) above vapor pressure as a starting rule, checked for each application.[6, 7]

Summarized in our own words from the forum discussions and articles listed under Sources. These are other people’s reports, not Sorque peer reviews, and they never count toward ratings.

Types of industrial pumps

Pumps fall into two families. Centrifugal (rotodynamic) pumps add velocity with an impeller and convert it to pressure; positive displacement pumps trap a fixed volume and push it out. The DOE credits the dominance of centrifugal pumps to low cost, light maintenance and long life, and favors positive displacement for viscous or shear-sensitive liquids, high pressure at low flow, metering and self-priming.

End suction centrifugal pumps

A single overhung impeller spins in a volute casing. Flow moves along the pump curve as system resistance changes.

Best for
Clean, thin liquids at moderate head: water, cooling water, light chemicals and hydrocarbons.
Watch out for
Short seal and bearing life far from BEP, thin NPSH margins and nozzle loads from piping. Performance drops as viscosity rises.

Horizontal split case pumps

A double-suction impeller runs between bearings in a casing split along the shaft, so the rotor lifts out without disturbing the piping.

Best for
High-flow water supply, cooling water, fire water and large circulation loops.
Watch out for
A suction elbow near the flange in a plane parallel to the shaft feeds the two impeller eyes unevenly. Large units need careful alignment.

Multistage centrifugal pumps

Several impellers in series on one shaft each add head.

Best for
High head at moderate flow: boiler feed, reverse osmosis feed, boosting and injection.
Watch out for
Tight clearances wear fast on dirty water, and dry running or low flow quickly damages internals.

Vertical turbine and submersible pumps

Impellers sit below the liquid surface, driven by a line shaft from a motor above grade or by a submerged motor, so no priming is needed.

Best for
Wells, sumps, intakes, cooling tower basins and drainage.
Watch out for
Low submergence lets vortices draw in air, and pulling the pump for repair takes lifting gear and time.

Magnetic drive and canned motor pumps

These sealless centrifugal pumps drive the impeller through a containment shell, and the pumped liquid lubricates the internal bearings.

Best for
Toxic, flammable or corrosive liquids where seal leakage is unacceptable.
Watch out for
Dry running, solids and very low flow quickly ruin the internal bearings. Chemical Processing names running below the thermal minimum flow as a particular risk for canned and sealless pumps.

Gear and lobe pumps

Meshing gears or lobes carry pockets of liquid to the outlet, so flow follows speed, less some slip back through the clearances.

Best for
Oils, resins, polymers and syrups, with lobe pumps for sanitary service.
Watch out for
Abrasives open clearances and dry running scores gears. Like all positive displacement pumps, they need relief protection.

Progressing cavity and screw pumps

A helical rotor turns in an elastomer stator, or intermeshing screws turn in a close-fitting housing, for smooth, low-pulsation flow.

Best for
Progressing cavity for sludge, slurries and pastes; screw pumps for fuel oil, lube oil and crude.
Watch out for
Stators fail from dry running, heat and chemical attack, and abrasives wear screw clearances open.

Diaphragm and peristaltic pumps

A flexing diaphragm with check valves, or rollers squeezing a hose, moves the liquid. As the DOE notes, neither needs a shaft seal.

Best for
Corrosive or abrasive chemicals, slurries, drum and tote transfer, and dosing.
Watch out for
Diaphragms and hoses fail from fatigue, and pulsation may need dampeners. Air-operated units use a lot of compressed air.

Reciprocating piston and plunger pumps

Pistons or plungers stroke in cylinders with check valves. Metering versions set flow by stroke length or speed.

Best for
High pressure at low flow: jetting, hydrotesting, chemical injection and metering.
Watch out for
Pulsation, valve and packing wear, and more spare parts. Suction piping must allow for acceleration head, and the discharge needs relief protection.

Common pump problems and solutions

Start with measurements, not parts: record suction and discharge pressure, flow, speed and current, and plot the operating point on the curve. As Pumps & Systems explains, a point on the curve clears the pump and shifts suspicion to the system or the liquid.

Cavitation

Symptoms
Crackling like gravel in the pump, unsteady pressure and current, lost head, and pitting near the impeller eye.
Likely causes
Pressure at the impeller eye drops below vapor pressure. The DOE lists low suction pressure, liquid hotter than design, starved or fouled suction, and running far right on the curve. Per the Hydraulic Institute, a pump at its published NPSH3 is already cavitating.
What to do
Calculate NPSH available in absolute terms from measured suction pressure, and rule out air entrainment. Then raise suction level or pressure, shorten or enlarge the suction line, clean strainers, cool the liquid, or move the duty toward BEP.
Sources
1, 2, 5

Low-flow operation and recirculation

Symptoms
Noise and vibration at low throughput that ease at higher flow, short seal and bearing life, and a hot casing.
Likely causes
Throttling, oversizing or deep drive turndown pushes the pump below minimum flow. The Hydraulic Institute links this to recirculation and added load, the DOE to shaft deflection, and Chemical Processing warns that below the thermal minimum the liquid can heat enough to wreck seals quickly.
What to do
Compare measured flow with the manufacturer’s minimum continuous flow, then add a minimum-flow bypass (often a restriction orifice), set a minimum drive speed, restage parallel pumps or resize.
Sources
1, 2, 8, 10, 11

Mechanical seal leaks and short seal life

Symptoms
Leakage beyond the seal maker’s allowance, chipped or heat-checked faces, damaged O-rings, and failures that return after every rebuild.
Likely causes
The DOE names dirty faces, overheating from poor lubrication and installation errors. Dry running, cavitation, misalignment, pipe strain, elastomer attack and too little seal chamber pressure above vapor pressure are other common causes.
What to do
Check alignment, flange fit-up, operating point and suction conditions before fitting another seal. Examine the failed parts, and review the flush plan, seal arrangement and elastomers with the seal supplier.
Sources
1, 6, 7, 9

Bearing overheating and failure

Symptoms
Rising housing temperature, rumble, vibration at bearing defect frequencies, and milky or dirty oil.
Likely causes
The DOE cites high loads, poor lubrication, heat, vibration and overgreasing. Plant Services adds water in the oil and casings distorted by forced piping.
What to do
Lubricate per the manual, keep water out (Plant Services favors non-contacting bearing housing seals), and trend vibration, temperature and oil. Bearings that last only months point to operating conditions or bearing design, according to the DOE.
Sources
1, 6, 9

Excessive vibration and noise

Symptoms
Rising vibration, loosening flanges, and cracked welds or supports.
Likely causes
Misalignment, soft foot, pipe strain, unbalance from wear or cavitation damage, or running far from BEP. The DOE notes that oversized pumps cause flow-induced pipe vibration.
What to do
Use vibration analysis to separate mechanical from hydraulic causes, then correct alignment and soft foot, support the piping independently, and move the duty toward BEP.
Sources
1, 6

Pump not building pressure or rated flow

Symptoms
The process can’t reach design flow or pressure.
Likely causes
Per Pumps & Systems, low flow at high head suggests a restriction, and low head at high flow means liquid is escaping through a leak, an open bypass or a failed check valve. Viscosity or specific gravity changes also shift performance. Inside the pump, look for a damaged or blocked impeller, wrong speed or worn wear rings.
What to do
Plot the operating point, confirm speed and rotation, and check liquid properties. If it stays below the curve after ruling out air and cavitation, open the pump and restore clearances.
Sources
1, 5

Loss of prime and air entrainment

Symptoms
Little or no flow, surging, or noise like cavitation.
Likely causes
Air leaks at suction joints or packing under vacuum, vortices at low submergence, or returns falling near the suction. The DOE notes that air drawn past packing can cut performance by 3% or more and stop a pump from holding prime.
What to do
Stop the pump promptly, since running dry can damage the seal. Fill and vent the casing, leak-check suction joints and packing, keep the inlet submerged, and route returns below the liquid level.
Sources
1, 5

Oversized pump wasting energy

Symptoms
The DOE lists flow noise, heavily throttled valves, heavy bypass use, frequent bearing and seal replacement, and intermittent operation.
Likely causes
Margins for design uncertainty, fouling and future capacity stack up.
What to do
Measure the real duty, then trim the impeller for a permanent cut, add a variable speed drive where flow varies, or replace the pump. By the affinity laws, power falls roughly with the cube of impeller diameter. The DOE notes that trimming can raise NPSH required and rarely goes below 70% of original diameter.
Sources
1, 11, 12

Rating pumps on Sorque

Every Sorque review scores equipment from 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A, on the same five metrics. For pumps, these are the things worth weighing:

Effectiveness
Does it deliver the required flow and head with the real liquid across the operating range, and stay stable at the lowest flow you need?
Reliability
Compare time between seal and bearing repairs with similar pumps in similar service. Say whether failures came from the pump or the system, and where it runs relative to BEP.
Maintenance
Consider how easily seals, bearings, wear parts, stators or diaphragms can be replaced, and the cost and availability of parts. Back pull-out designs and cartridge seals count.
Efficiency
Consider measured efficiency at the actual duty, closeness to BEP, whether flow is controlled by speed or throttling, and how fast performance falls with wear.
Downtime/replaceability
Consider repair or swap time, whether there is an installed spare, whether the pump comes out without disturbing piping, and parts lead time.

Industrial pump maintenance checklist

Set intervals from the manual, downtime cost, spare availability and repair history. The DOE’s sample schedule below is a starting point, not a rule.

  • Before repairs, authorized personnel must apply the site’s lockout/tagout procedure (OSHA 29 CFR 1910.147 in the U.S.) and isolate, drain and depressurize the pump. Hazardous, hot or pressurized liquids need the site’s permit and line-breaking procedures.
  • On rounds, listen for cavitation and bearing noise, compare pressures and current with baseline, and check for leaks.
  • Weekly, adjust packing glands to the manufacturer’s leakage rate (usually 2 to 60 drops per minute, according to the DOE), following site rules for work near rotating shafts. Never tighten packing until it runs dry.
  • Weekly, check seal leakage, flush flow, and barrier fluid level and pressure on dual seals.
  • Lubricate bearings as the manual specifies; the DOE’s sample schedule suggests semiannually or annually. Don’t overgrease, and check oil for water and debris.
  • Trend vibration and bearing temperature, adding oil analysis or thermography on critical pumps.
  • Recheck alignment and soft foot after any piping or foundation work.
  • Test flow, head and power against the curve; a steady decline points to worn wear rings or impellers.
  • Clean suction strainers and confirm suction valves are fully open.
  • Test relief valves on positive displacement pumps on a fixed schedule.
  • Record every failure with its root cause.

How to choose an industrial pump

Start with the system, not the catalog; the DOE notes that covering design uncertainty often leads to oversized pumps.

Real duty and system curve
Calculate static and friction head for the real piping, define minimum, normal and maximum flow, and don’t stack safety margins.
Operating point near BEP
Pick a pump whose BEP sits near normal flow, and get its allowable operating region and minimum continuous flow from the manufacturer (see ANSI/HI 9.6.3).
NPSH margin
Compare NPSH available at the lowest level, highest temperature and highest flow with NPSH3 plus the margin ANSI/HI 9.6.1 recommends.
Liquid properties
Viscosity, solids, shear sensitivity, vapor pressure and temperature decide between centrifugal and positive displacement designs.
Sealing and materials
Packing where some leakage is acceptable, mechanical seals for most services, and dual seals or sealless pumps for hazardous liquids. Match wetted materials to corrosion and erosion.
Flow control
According to the DOE, speed control is the most efficient way to vary centrifugal pump flow and bypass usually the least. Where static head dominates, check low-speed operation against minimum flow.
Efficiency and life-cycle cost
Compare efficiency at your duty point and life-cycle cost, not purchase price. Covered U.S. clean water pumps made on or after January 27, 2020 must meet the DOE Pump Energy Index standard (10 CFR 431.465).
Maintainability and downtime
Back pull-out designs, cartridge seals, standard spares, independent pipe supports and installed spares on critical services shorten outages.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main types of industrial pumps?

Industrial pumps are either centrifugal (rotodynamic) or positive displacement. Centrifugal types include end suction, split case, multistage, vertical turbine, submersible and sealless pumps. Positive displacement types include gear, lobe, progressing cavity, screw, diaphragm, peristaltic, and piston or plunger pumps.

What is the difference between centrifugal and positive displacement pumps?

A centrifugal pump’s flow changes with system resistance along its curve. A positive displacement pump moves a nearly fixed volume per revolution or stroke, so flow follows speed and pressure keeps rising against a blocked discharge. That is why it needs relief protection, and it handles viscous liquids and metering better than a centrifugal pump.

What causes pump cavitation and how do you prevent it?

Cavitation occurs when pressure at the impeller eye falls below vapor pressure, so vapor bubbles form and collapse against the impeller. Common causes are a low suction level, restricted suction, hot liquid and running far out on the curve. Prevent it by raising NPSH available and running near BEP.

What causes mechanical seal failure in pumps?

Direct causes are usually dirty faces, overheating, dry running and installation errors. Repeat failures often trace back to pipe strain, misalignment, low flow, elastomer attack or too little seal chamber pressure above vapor pressure, so fix the cause before fitting another seal.

What is the best efficiency point of a pump?

The best efficiency point (BEP) is the flow at which a centrifugal pump is most efficient. The DOE notes that radial bearing loads are also lowest there for most casing designs. Running far to either side raises energy use, vibration, and seal and bearing wear.

What is the difference between NPSHA and NPSHR?

NPSH available (NPSHA) is what the system supplies: absolute head at the pump suction minus the liquid’s vapor pressure. NPSH required is what the pump needs, usually published as NPSH3, where cavitation has already cut head by 3%. NPSHA should exceed NPSH3 by a margin, with ANSI/HI 9.6.1 as the usual guide.

How often should industrial pumps be serviced?

Follow the manual, then adjust for each pump’s repair history and criticality. For typical service, the DOE’s sample schedule calls for weekly packing and seal checks and semiannual or annual bearing lubrication. Vibration and oil analysis let you time repairs to actual condition.

How do you increase pump efficiency?

Measure the actual duty first, because oversized, throttled pumps waste the most energy. Trim the impeller for a permanent reduction, use speed control where flow varies, and restore worn clearances. A DOE-commissioned study found that pump efficiency can degrade by as much as 10% to 25% before replacement.

Why does a pump keep losing prime?

Most centrifugal pumps are not self-priming, so the casing and suction line must stay full. Common causes are air leaks at suction joints or packing, a leaking foot valve, vortices at low submergence, and returns that entrain air. Stop a pump that runs without flow, because running dry can damage the seal.

Peer reviews of pumps

Rated 1 to 10 by engineers, mechanics, and technicians who have run or maintained them.

Add an equipment review

Ratings1 (poor) - 10 (great), N/A (Not applicable)

How well does it achieve its intended purpose, e.g., measurement accuracy of sensors. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

How likely is it to fail or seize. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

Effort and attention needed to maintain high quality operation. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

Performance/cost - can be energy, economic, or other costs. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

Length of time from breakdown to operation and ease of securing replacements. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

At least 20 characters. Reviews are public; leave out names and confidential details.

Sources

Pages this guide draws on, checked when it was last updated. Links go to other sites.

  1. Improving Pumping System Performance: A Sourcebook for Industry (Second Edition) · U.S. Department of Energy
  2. The Basics of NPSH & Pump Operating Regions · Hydraulic Institute
  3. 10 CFR 431.465 - Pumps energy conservation standards and their compliance dates · Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  4. Control of Hazardous Energy (Lockout/Tagout) - Overview · U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration
  5. Solutions to Common Centrifugal Pump Problems · Pumps & Systems
  6. How Do Plant Pipe Strain Problems Affect My Pumping Systems? · Pumps & Systems (Fluid Sealing Association, Sealing Sense)
  7. What Should My Seal Chamber Pressure Be? · Pumps & Systems (Hydraulic Institute, HI Pump FAQs)
  8. Protect Pumps and the Bottom Line · Chemical Processing
  9. The FRETT approach · Plant Services
  10. General Causes Of Centrifugal Pumps Failure · Cheresources.com Community
  11. Pump Bypass And Minimum Flow · Cheresources.com Community
  12. Excessive Pump TDH And How To Deal With It? · Cheresources.com Community