Sorque home

Equipment guide

Types of storage tanks: common problems, inspection and selection

Industrial storage tanks hold crude oil, fuels, chemicals, water and finished product at plants, refineries and terminals, often for decades. Knowing the types of storage tanks and how each fails matters because the failures are not intuitive: a steel tank built for slight internal pressure can be crushed by a small vacuum, and a corroding floor can leak unseen until product appears at the chime or in the soil.

This guide covers the main tank types, the problems inspectors and engineers report most often, inspection and maintenance basics, and how to choose a tank. The focus is atmospheric and low-pressure tanks; refrigerated tanks, spheres and bullets are covered briefly because the line between a tank and a pressure vessel decides which code applies.

Vent sizing, overfill protection, hot work, tank entry and fitness-for-service decisions belong with qualified engineers, certified tank inspectors and the codes that apply at your site. Use this page for orientation, then read the peer reviews below.

Updated · Written for engineers, mechanics, and technicians

Web summary · not a peer review

What people are saying elsewhere

Process engineers on forums, and the safety bulletins they cite, keep returning to a short list of failures. Collapsed tanks are usually traced to a vent that was covered, plugged, frozen or never sized for the real outflow, not to a weak shell. Floor leaks are blamed on water under the plates and on cathodic protection that never reaches the floor; floating roof and blanketing trouble, on drains, pontoons, vapor under the deck and regulators that fail silently. The recurring advice is to fix the root cause, not just the damaged steel.

  • Collapses start at the vent. Bulletins and forum posts describe tanks crushed after plastic was left over a vent, after vents plugged with wax or a bee nest, and after a steam-filled tank was closed in and cooled. Others warn that a ruptured hose or wide-open pump can outrun a vent sized for the nominal pump-out rate.[9, 10, 11]
  • One level gauge is not enough. Federal investigators found a float-and-tape gauge was the only barrier when a Puerto Rico terminal tank overflowed in 2009. Forum engineers add that a tank going from empty to full in about 30 minutes gives operators little margin after an alarm, and favor independent high and high-high level shutdowns.[5, 11]
  • Floor leaks start under the plates. Corrosion engineers describe rainwater entering through failed chime-to-ringwall seals and held against bare steel by older asphalt-and-sand pads. In one published case, cathodic protection readings looked fine while most of the current leaked into connected plant piping.[14, 15]
  • Floating roofs fail through drains, pontoons and vapor. Reported causes of tilted or sunk roofs include flooded pontoons, blocked roof drains, out-of-round shells or bent guides that jam the roof, and high vapor pressure feed flashing under the deck.[12, 14]
  • Blanket gas systems fail quietly. Operators note that a self-contained blanketing regulator gives no signal when it fails and that pressure/vacuum valves can freeze in winter, and suggest pressure alarms or an oxygen analyzer. A regulator stuck open can overpressure the tank; one stuck closed leaves it exposed to vacuum.[7, 13]

Summarized in our own words from the forum discussions and articles listed under Sources. These are other people’s reports, not Sorque peer reviews, and they never count toward ratings.

Types of storage tanks

Tanks are grouped by roof design, pressure, temperature, location and material. EPA’s AP-42 lists six basic designs for organic liquids: fixed roof, external floating roof, domed external floating roof, internal floating roof, variable vapor space and pressure tanks.

Fixed roof tanks (cone and dome roof)

A vertical steel shell with a permanent cone, dome or flat roof whose vapor space breathes through open or pressure/vacuum vents. AP-42 notes it is the lowest-cost design to build.

Best for
Diesel, fuel oil, lube oil, asphalt, water and many chemicals, often under a nitrogen blanket.
Watch out for
Evaporative losses on volatile products and very little vacuum tolerance. Raise vent settings only if the tank was designed for the higher pressure.

External floating roof tanks

An open-top shell with a welded steel pontoon or double-deck roof floating on the product, sealed to the shell by rim seals. Losses come from rim seals, deck fittings and product left on the shell, with wind the main driver per AP-42.

Best for
Large volumes of crude oil, gasoline and other volatile liquids.
Watch out for
Rain and snow loads, roof drains, rim seal wear, pontoon leaks, and roof landings on the legs, which open a vapor space and add emissions.

Internal floating roof tanks

A fixed roof over a floating deck, often aluminum, that rests on the liquid or rides on pontoons just above it; AP-42 says non-contact decks are most common. According to AP-42, circulation vents in the fixed roof reduce the chance that vapor above the deck reaches the flammable range, but it still can, so follow your site’s gas-testing and permit procedures before any entry or hot work.

Best for
Volatile products kept free of rainwater, and emission retrofits: AP-42 puts the reduction from adding an internal floating roof to a fixed roof tank at 60 to 99 percent.
Watch out for
Leaking bolted deck seams and fittings, decks binding on columns or guide poles, and pontoons that lose buoyancy with no sign from outside.

Horizontal shop-built tanks

Shop-fabricated cylinders on saddles or skids, single-wall, double-wall or diked. Per AP-42 they are generally under 40,000 gallons, no longer than six diameters, and made of steel, fiberglass-clad steel or fiberglass-reinforced polyester.

Best for
Generator and fleet fuel, day tanks, lube oil and small chemical inventories.
Watch out for
Corrosion at saddles and the low end, and interstitial leak monitoring on double-wall units.

Low-pressure tanks

Field-erected tanks with heavier roofs, anchorage and pressure/vacuum relief. OSHA defines a low-pressure tank as one designed for more than 0.5 psig and up to 15 psig and lists API 620 as an accepted design standard; API 650 tanks go up to 2.5 psig.

Best for
Higher vapor pressure liquids and blanketed chemicals that need a positive pressure pad.
Watch out for
Shell uplift, anchor bolts, and relief settings that must match the nameplate pressure and vacuum ratings.

Refrigerated tanks

Insulated tanks holding a liquefied gas near its atmospheric boiling point (about -28°F for ammonia, -260°F for LNG) at slight positive pressure, with boil-off reliquefied by refrigeration compressors.

Best for
Large inventories of ammonia, LPG and LNG where pressurized storage would be too heavy or costly.
Watch out for
Loss of refrigeration, pump recirculation heat and rollover of stratified liquid, all overpressure causes in API 2000 per AIChE.

Pressurized spheres and bullets

Pressure vessels holding liquefied gas at its own vapor pressure: bullets are horizontal cylinders, spheres suit larger volumes. OSHA’s flammable liquids standard treats tanks designed above 15 psig as pressure vessels.

Best for
Propane, butane, LPG, natural gas liquids and ammonia at ambient temperature.
Watch out for
Fire-case relief sizing, corrosion under fireproofing on sphere legs, and jurisdictional pressure vessel inspections.

Underground storage tanks (USTs)

Buried steel or fiberglass tanks, often double-wall. EPA defines a UST system as a tank plus underground piping with at least 10 percent of the combined volume below ground, and counts about 534,000 active petroleum USTs in the U.S.

Best for
Retail and fleet fueling where space or fire separation rules out an aboveground tank.
Watch out for
Unseen leaks into groundwater. Federal rules require leak detection, spill and overfill controls and inspection at least every three years.

Plastic and fiberglass tanks

Rotationally molded linear or cross-linked polyethylene, or fiberglass-reinforced plastic (FRP) with a resin-rich corrosion barrier. Polyethylene tanks carry a specific gravity rating, from 1.0 to 1.9 or more according to Ontario’s agriculture ministry.

Best for
Acids, caustic, water treatment chemicals and liquid fertilizers in small to mid-size volumes.
Watch out for
Sunlight, strong oxidizers, rigid piping at fittings, overweight product, and heat: Ontario’s guidance says sustained temperatures above 37°C (99°F) may weaken polyethylene tanks.

Common storage tank problems and how to fix them

Most serious tank incidents trace back to a few causes. The fixes below are a starting point for your tank engineer and inspector, not a repair procedure.

Vacuum collapse (tank implosion)

Symptoms
Buckled roof plates or an inward-dished upper shell after a pump-out, rainstorm, cold night or steam-out.
Likely causes
Air cannot enter as fast as liquid leaves or vapor contracts: vents covered or plugged with wax, ice or nests, steam condensing in a closed tank, a blanket regulator failing closed, or a drain, ruptured hose or broken nozzle outrunning a vent sized for the pump.
What to do
Size vacuum relief for every inbreathing case with API 2000, which OSHA references. Track and remove temporary vent covers, inspect vents in fouling or freezing service, and never close in a steam-filled tank. A collapsed tank needs a qualified engineer’s assessment before reuse.
Sources
2, 7, 9, 10, 11, 13

Overpressure and roof or bottom damage

Symptoms
Bulged roof plates, a torn roof-to-shell joint, a lifted floor edge, or relief devices that lift often.
Likely causes
Filling faster than vents relieve, a blanket regulator stuck open, leaking steam coils, hot feed, incompatible mixing and fire exposure.
What to do
Assign a safeguard to each credible case, provide fire-case emergency venting as OSHA requires, and test vents, regulators and relief devices on a schedule.
Sources
2, 7

Overfill

Symptoms
Product from vents or overflow lines, liquid in the dike, or a vapor cloud.
Likely causes
Failed gauges, valve line-up errors, fast transfers and a single layer of protection. In the 2009 Puerto Rico terminal explosion the CSB found no independent high-level alarm; the vapor cloud covered about 107 acres and roughly 300 homes and businesses were damaged.
What to do
Add an independent high-level alarm or automatic shutoff with enough response time. EPA’s SPCC rule requires at least one overfill prevention device on oil tanks and regular testing of level sensors.
Sources
3, 5, 7

Tank floor corrosion and leaks

Symptoms
Product at leak detection ports, the chime or the dike, inventory loss, or pitting found by floor scanning on either face of the plates.
Likely causes
Underneath: water entering through poor drainage or failed chime seals, pads that hold it against bare steel, microbes, and cathodic protection that is missing or whose current leaks to connected piping. Inside: settled water carrying chlorides, hydrogen sulfide, carbon dioxide or organic acids, and unsuitable linings.
What to do
Floor scanning with ultrasonic follow-up, restored drainage and chime seals, regular water draw-off, and cathodic protection surveys that measure current in connected piping, not only potentials. Repair under API 653 and correct the cause, or the leak returns.
Sources
14, 15

Floating roof tilting, sinking or binding

Symptoms
Roof out of level, product or water on the deck, rim seal gaps, or a roof that stops following the level.
Likely causes
Flooded pontoons, blocked roof drains, seals or legs jammed by an out-of-round shell or bent guides, settlement, and high vapor pressure feed flashing under the deck.
What to do
Stop transfers, find and fix the cause, then refill in stages while watching roof travel. Product on a tilted or sunk roof raises fire risk, so it is a job for trained responders.
Sources
12, 14

Foundation settlement

Symptoms
Shell out of plumb or round, a binding floating roof, ringwall cracks, or water pooling at the chime.
Likely causes
Soft or variable soils, consolidation of saturated clay, snow loads, and eroded foundation shoulders.
What to do
Survey on a schedule and screen with API 653 Annex B. Uniform settlement and tilt are often tolerable with flexible piping; differential and edge settlement need engineering review, sometimes under API 579.
Sources
14, 16

Fires and explosions during hot work

Symptoms
Combustible gas readings near tanks believed empty, or vapor drifting from neighboring tanks and vents.
Likely causes
Welding, cutting or grinding igniting vapor in the tank or an adjacent one. The CSB ranks hot work among the most common causes of worker deaths it investigates.
What to do
Apply the CSB’s lessons: pick a cold method where one exists, assess the hazards, drain or purge, gas-test the work area and every adjacent tank before and during the job, work under a written permit, train crews, and oversee contractors.
Sources
6, 7

Cracking of plastic tanks

Symptoms
Crazing, whitened areas and cracks radiating from fittings.
Likely causes
Ultraviolet exposure, heat, strong oxidizers, rigid piping loading the fittings, and product heavier than the rating.
What to do
Inspect before each fill and after use, and use flexible connections. Ontario’s agriculture ministry recommends replacing crazed or cracked polyethylene tanks, since repairs are unreliable.
Sources
19

Rating storage tanks on Sorque

Every Sorque review scores equipment from 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A, on the same five metrics. For storage tanks, these are the things worth weighing:

Effectiveness
Does the tank hold its working capacity and deliver product on spec? Consider water and rust contamination, vapor control and level measurement accuracy.
Reliability
Consider time between leaks and between failures of vents, seals, roof drains, coils and level instruments, and whether internal inspections matched predicted corrosion.
Maintenance
Consider the ease and cost of inspection, cleaning and repair: manway and cleanout access, sludge removal, lining life, and safe access to vents and gauges.
Efficiency
Consider evaporative losses (rim seals, fittings, roof landings), heat loss from heated tanks, nitrogen use on blanketed tanks, and usable versus nominal volume.
Downtime/replaceability
Consider time out of service for internal inspection and repair, whether a spare tank can carry the service, and lead times for floors, seals or a replacement tank.

Storage tank inspection and maintenance checklist

For welded steel tanks, API 653's default maximums, as summarized by Reliable magazine, are monthly in-service inspections by the owner, a formal external inspection by an authorized inspector at least every five years, and a first internal inspection normally at 10 years, extendable by credits to 20 or 30 years. Risk-based inspection, your spill plan and permits can change the actual schedule.

  • Walk each tank for leaks at the chime, nozzles and seams, coating breakdown, shell bulges and oil in the dike.
  • Check vents, flame arresters and pressure/vacuum valves for plugging, ice and nests, and confirm temporary covers are gone.
  • Test high-level alarms and shutoffs against manual gauging; the SPCC rule requires regular level sensor testing.
  • Compare blanketing regulator performance with vapor-space pressure readings.
  • Draw off and record water bottoms; a sudden increase can signal a roof drain, seal or coil leak.
  • On floating roofs, keep drains clear and check pontoons, rim seals, guide poles and roof level.
  • Inspect the ringwall, chime seal and drainage, and record cathodic protection readings.
  • Keep dike drain valves closed and release rainwater only after checking for oil.
  • Survey settlement at planned intervals, more often in early service.
  • Schedule thickness readings and internal floor, weld and lining inspections with a certified inspector.
  • Before entry or hot work, require permits, isolation, gas-freeing and continuous gas monitoring by trained personnel.

How to choose a storage tank

Start with the product, then work out to pressure class, roof, material, foundation and containment.

Product properties
Vapor pressure at maximum storage temperature, flash point, specific gravity and corrosivity. OSHA does not allow a flammable liquid in an atmospheric tank at or above its boiling point.
Pressure class and code
OSHA classes tanks as atmospheric up to 0.5 psig, low-pressure up to 15 psig, and pressure vessels above that. Per Petroleum Technology Quarterly, API 650 covers designs up to 2.5 psig; OSHA lists API 620 for low-pressure tanks.
Roof type and emissions
Fixed roofs for low-volatility products, floating roofs for volatile ones; practitioners warn that very high vapor pressure feed can flash under a floating deck. Check air permit limits.
Material of construction
Carbon steel for most hydrocarbons; stainless steel, FRP or polyethylene for corrosive chemicals. The SPCC rule requires oil containers compatible with the oil and its storage conditions.
Capacity and spares
Size on working capacity between the heel and the high-level alarm. A spare tank allows internal inspection without a shutdown.
Venting and overfill protection
Size normal and emergency venting to API 2000 for every credible case, decide on a nitrogen blanket, and add an independent high-level alarm or shutoff.
Foundation and access
Get a geotechnical investigation, drain water away from the chime, avoid asphalt pads on new tanks, and specify manways, cleanouts and a sloped floor.
Containment and regulations
The SPCC rule applies to facilities that could discharge oil to navigable waters and store more than 1,320 gallons aboveground in containers of 55 gallons or more, and requires containment for the largest container plus rainfall freeboard.

Frequently asked questions

What are the main types of storage tanks?

The main types are fixed roof, external and internal floating roof, low-pressure, refrigerated, pressurized spheres and bullets, horizontal shop-built, underground, and plastic or fiberglass tanks. The product’s vapor pressure, volume and corrosivity usually decide which fits.

What is the difference between a fixed roof and a floating roof tank?

A fixed roof tank has a vapor space that vents as the tank fills or warms. A floating roof rides on the liquid, removing most of that vapor space and cutting evaporative losses, so it is used for volatile liquids such as crude oil and gasoline.

What is the difference between an internal and an external floating roof tank?

An external floating roof is open to rain, snow and wind, and wind drives most of its rim seal losses. An internal floating roof sits under a fixed roof that keeps weather off the deck and removes those wind-driven losses.

What is the difference between API 650 and API 653?

API 650 covers design and construction of new welded steel tanks for oil storage, up to 2.5 psig. API 653 covers tanks in service: inspection, repair, alteration, relocation and reconstruction.

How often is an API 653 inspection required?

By API 653's default rules, owners inspect in service at least monthly and an authorized inspector does a formal external inspection at least every five years. The first internal inspection is normally due at 10 years, extendable to 20 or 30, and later intervals depend on measured floor corrosion.

What causes a storage tank to implode?

Pressure inside drops below atmospheric faster than the vents can admit air, typically during pump-out with a covered or plugged vent, or when steam condenses in a closed tank. Atmospheric tanks are built for slight internal pressure, so a small vacuum can buckle them.

What is the purpose of a nitrogen blanket on a storage tank?

A nitrogen blanket keeps air and moisture out of the vapor space, preventing a flammable mixture, and replaces withdrawn volume to help prevent vacuum. The regulator needs regular maintenance, and vented nitrogen is an asphyxiation hazard.

What is the difference between a storage tank and a pressure vessel?

Under OSHA’s flammable liquids standard, atmospheric tanks are designed for up to 0.5 psig and low-pressure tanks for up to 15 psig. Anything designed above 15 psig is a pressure vessel, built to ASME Section VIII and inspected under rules such as API 510.

What regulations apply to aboveground storage tanks?

In the U.S., EPA’s SPCC rule covers facilities that could discharge oil to navigable waters and store more than 1,320 gallons aboveground or 42,000 gallons completely buried. OSHA’s flammable liquids standard, fire codes, air permits and state rules may also apply.

Peer reviews of storage tanks

Rated 1 to 10 by engineers, mechanics, and technicians who have run or maintained them.

Add an equipment review

Ratings1 (poor) - 10 (great), N/A (Not applicable)

How well does it achieve its intended purpose, e.g., measurement accuracy of sensors. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

How likely is it to fail or seize. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

Effort and attention needed to maintain high quality operation. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

Performance/cost - can be energy, economic, or other costs. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

Length of time from breakdown to operation and ease of securing replacements. Enter 1 (poor) to 10 (great), or N/A.

At least 20 characters. Reviews are public; leave out names and confidential details.

Sources

Pages this guide draws on, checked when it was last updated. Links go to other sites.

  1. AP-42 Section 7.1: Organic Liquid Storage Tanks · U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
  2. 29 CFR 1910.106 Flammable liquids · U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration
  3. 40 CFR 112.8 Spill Prevention, Control, and Countermeasure Plan requirements for onshore facilities · Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (text of EPA regulation)
  4. Does the Spill Prevention, Control, and Countermeasure (SPCC) Rule Apply to Your Facility? · U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
  5. CSB Approves Final Investigation Report and Video from 2009 Explosion and Fire at Caribbean Petroleum Terminal Facility in Puerto Rico · U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board
  6. Safe Hot Work Practices · U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation Board
  7. Protect Tanks from Overpressure and Vacuum (Chemical Engineering Progress, December 2019) · American Institute of Chemical Engineers (AIChE)
  8. Designing storage tanks (PTQ, October 2016) · Petroleum Technology Quarterly / DigitalRefining
  9. Vacuum Hazards: Collapsed Tanks (Process Safety Beacon, February 2007) · AIChE Center for Chemical Process Safety (CCPS)
  10. Vacuum pulled up in a tank during steam purging · Cheresources.com Community
  11. Emergency vent in storage atmospheric water tanks · Cheresources.com Community
  12. Condensate storage tank selection · Cheresources.com Community
  13. Control valves vs. regulators for tank blanketing · Cheresources.com Community
  14. AST tank emergencies: API 653 repair to recover service · Inspenet
  15. Cathodic Protection Considerations for AST External Bottom Plates (Materials Performance, January 2023) · Association for Materials Protection and Performance (AMPP)
  16. A Deep Dive into Aboveground Storage Tank Settlement Evaluation · The Equity Engineering Group
  17. API 510, 570, and 653 Inspection Intervals: Vessels, Piping, and Tanks · Reliable magazine (Reliable Media)
  18. Learn About Underground Storage Tanks (USTs) · U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
  19. Poly tanks for farms: tank inspection · Ontario Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Agribusiness